Jewish People should abandon
the Modern State of Israel.
The State of Israel is Corrupt,
evil , and it's hurting Judism as
a religion.
I know this going to be a painful subject. I had addressed the big problem with the " modern state of Israel" . I personally want to say , I don't HATE Jews , but am bewildered on how the modern state of Israel is creating a morass of a problem for Jews . Many Jews can't break out of the devilish spell that the Zionists created . Israeli government is CAUSING antisemitism. Do these people crave
victimhood?? NO!!! ... Always getting blamed, hated, kicked out, killed,
etc......... It's a question I have had in my mind for decades. Why why ???It's ongoing war with the Palestinians. The Zionists have done in the last three years since October 7th, 2023 more damage to the Jewish community than all the Nazis would have done to stoke " anti semitic" feelings through out the world. It's A SHAME that no RABBI has dared to denounce the current Israeli government on corruption charges, knowing that Zionists have made Jewish people around the world more vunerable for Israel's entire existence. The behavior of the government of the modern state of Israel fallen right in line with the same language the Nazis used twards other races. Zionism was a fringe mix of British Isrealism and militant Judiasm extremist belief that was widely sneered at among Jews before World War II. The beginnings of the Israeli state were Zionists profitieering off the Holocaust as they've done year after year. Israel has abused, humiliated, impoverished and wantonly killed
Palestinians, provoking inevitable counter violence. It is the engine
behind a century of bloodshed. The genocide in Gaza outdoes even the
worst excesses of the Nakba,
or catastrophe, which saw 750,000 Palestinians driven from their land
in 1948 and 8,000 to 15,000 murdered in massacres by Zionist terrorist
militias such as Irgun and Lehi. Modern ISRAEL has become evil, is harmful to anyone who faithfully Jewish. No actual Jew would say that Jews are the world''s only ethnic group legally permitted by
international authorities to employ a political ideology to justify
removal of an indigenous population from their land. To paraphrase
Hillel, "The rest is commentary, now go and learn". The Bible has warned Jews through the Prophets about " pride" and " sin" , which has led to the destruction of ancient Israel and Judah, yes because of pride . Modern ISRAEL is prideful , it's sinking like a Sodom and Gomorrah. Real Jews need to separate themselves from that Israel, the modern state, and start to focus on their SPIRITUAL HERATEGE , and not the wiles of a government like Bibi Natanyahu's dystopia. There were Jewish voices who advocated for coexistence with the
Palestinians like Brit Shalom movement and even though they didn't
oppose Jewish settlement in palestine they were viewed as anti zionist
just for opposing the idea of a Jewish national state .. So yes the
zionist movement from the start excluded non jews and wanted them out ..
.. Allowing a token minority to exist after expulsion of the majority
of the Palestinians is not exactly an evidence against this .. there will never be PEACE š️ as long as Zionists continues to control the Jewish Community.
Not All Jews Are Semites .
Many Jews are Jews by Conversion not actually Semites. Many Jews who are in modern Israel have their own roots traced back to Europe, like Poland , Russia etc. To " claim" that Jews are Semites has led to racial marginalizing a group of people who are a " religious" group, limiting them to a specific category. This "comeback" to accusations of antisemitism regarding the
Arab-Israeli conflict seems so ridiculous to me, yet I keep seeing it
crop up as the ultimate retort. If you think about it for more than a
few seconds, there are several glaring flaws with this logic:The first of these is that "antisemitism" simply means a prejudice
against Jews. It has nothing to do with "Semites." Applying the term
across the board based on technical root words is like calling a spider
an octopus because it also has eight legs.Second, and related to the first, is that "Semites"... aren't
really a thing (edit: racially). It's part of an outdated racial
ideology that was used by the Nazis. According to Wikipedia, for
example, "Semites is an obsolete term for an ethnic, cultural
or racial group associated with people of the Middle East,
including Arabs, Jews, Akkadians, and Phoenicians." Calling Arabs (or
Jews for that matter) Semites are borrowing from pseudoscientific racist
ideologies. (As several people pointed out, the term can be used
linguistically. On the other hand, it's typically used racially.)Third, this comeback is clearly disingenuous because people don't
call themselves or other groups "Semites" outside of their attempted
refutation of accusations of antisemitism. Nobody speaks about how
Egyptians/Armenians/Jordanians/anyone else are a proud nation of
Semites, etc.Finally, even if all of this was untrue, if these terms fit the scenario perfectly, it still
wouldn't make sense. Let's give a similar scenario: accusations of
racism. Imagine an Asian person accuses a Mexican person of racism.
Would anyone in their right mind consider "Well, Mexicans are also part
of a race" as a fair way to address those accusations? Of course not,
people would immediately point out how ridiculous such a statement would
be.I'm not interested in debating criticism of Israel vs antizionism
vs antisemitism (at least here). I'm just sick of this claim. It's been
stated very frequently, so is there any validity to it?
Israel a POLICE STATE?
THE head of Shin Bet, Israel’s internal intelligence service, Ronen Bar, filed an explosive 31-page affidavit in the country’s High Court of Justice, in essence accusing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of seeking to turn the country into a police state. So the Jewish promised land is under a petty dictatorship .The affidavit—filed after judges halted Bar’s firing by Netanyahu last month—alleges that the Shin Bet chief was told to conduct illegal espionage against democratic protests, obstruct the ongoing criminal trial of the Prime Minister, and disregard the courts as a constitutional crisis unfolds. The decision to fire Bar came even as Shin Bet investigated allegations that two of the Prime Minister’s top aides received payoffs from the state of Qatar.Few nations have stories of espionage—and its handmaidens, intrigue and deceit—so entwined with their origin myths. Few nations owe so much to their intelligence services for their survival, either.Even as Israel began its occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, the eminent Israeli philosopher Yeshayahu Leibowitz warned that “a country that controls a hostile population of a million foreigners will necessarily be a Shin Bet state, with everything that this requires, with implications on education, freedom of speech and thought and on democratic governance. The corruption characterising every colonial regime will also infect the State of Israel.”Israel and its apologists repeatedly portray Israel as “the only democracy in the Middle East,” a uniquely democratic regime in a non-democratic region. Somehow this is supposed to make us feel more sympathetic and justify our support of it. But Israeli democracy is a myth. Ask any Palestinian and they will tell you much worse stories — frankly, there is no comparison. Palestinians cannot help but be seen as outsiders, whether they are citizens of Israel or whether they are refugees in the Occupied Territories, whether they are children or adults, male or female. All Palestinians live under constant military and police surveillance. They experience nothing of the mythical Israeli democracy. “Israeli democracy” is something reserved only for the privileged and mostly ignorant elite, Palestinian citizens of Israel live under an arbitrary and brutal police state. Their dealings with Israeli bureaucracy are not just frustrating but can be outright dangerous. The Holy Land is not even safe .
Conclusion.
I understand that this is a provocative question, but I believe it's one worth examining. One of the key foundations of Zionism has long been that Antisemitism would always be a feature of societies in which Jews lived as minorities, and that only Jewish sovereignty could allow Jews to escape eternal persecution. Yet, the number of Jewish deaths due to violence has been significantly higher in Israel than any other country with a Jewish minority since the end of WWII. While it's undeniable that Antisemitism existed in the Middle East long before Zionism, it's also undeniable that it grew exponentially following the advent of the Zionist movement and the creation of Israel. Regardless of the fact that this hatred is wrong, the outcome has been violence being perpetrated against Jews as a direct consequence of the actions of the Zionist movement. Thus, one must ask: has Zionism in Israel actually served to keep Jewish people safer, or has it served to put them in harm's way?
